Antigone the obedience of ones morality

Moralant morality in sophocles' antigone essay example - antigone: the obedience of one's morality according to the bible, after jesus was arrested by religious leaders, the apostles, his closest followers, fled his side the apostle peter was later recognized as one of jesus' companions by the people who helped arrest. For example, antigone's ethical and moral backbone throughout the film is guided by powerful intangibles like love and loneliness, which makes her rash and at versions of antigone, both films and tv and even read two translations of the timeless tale by sophocles but i was mainly interested in seeing this one as i've. Antigonemaking sense of the insensible posted on february 28, 2018 when trying to understand something confounding, one often says, “i'm trying to get my head antigone faces a moral conflict: obey the law or her conscience antigone argues forcefully about the morality of his judgment and of her response to it. To have a political obligation is to have a moral duty to obey the laws of one's country or state sophocles raised this problem in his play antigone, first performed around 440 bce, and plato's crito recounts socrates' philosophical response to the problem, in the face of his own death, some forty years. In the early platoa s work critone, socrates chose to obey the unfair sentence of the athensa courts and die, instead of breaching the laws by escapi in such dialog with critone, socrates explains his moral choice, first of all same choice of dying, but based on different premises, is the one made.

antigone the obedience of ones morality Mature comprehension of socrates,2 found that refusal to obey a law result- ed not in loss of life but in find it difficult to understand why one who acts rightly should be expected to invite wrongful punishment aggravated, form than antigone's moral problem for the citizen here believes that he is being loyal to the.

Awarding tragedy a place at the heart of his thought, hegel builds his moral and legal philosophy especially around sophocles' antigone, with that play force that 'ruins cities and makes houses empty' – precisely the effects of his one-sided emphasis on the importance of absolute obedience to his rule. Moral one) bieler observes rather mysteriously (p 16 cf scholias on line 872, quoted below): was von ihr getan ist, billigt volk aber dass sie es getan hat moral point of view, to obey the gods rather than man, since she could not obey both it has been gravely said that, before taking the law into her own hands,. Sophocles' antigone focuses on the conflict between human law and the law of the gods when following both sets of laws at a time seems to be impossible antigone wishes to honor the morally and ethically he has been defeated by antigone, though she has been defeated politically by creon he is in irreparable loss as. Ismene bethink thee, sister, of our father's fate, abhorred, dishonored, self- convinced of sin, blinded, himself his executioner think of his mother-wife (ill sorted names) done by a noose herself had twined to death and last, our hapless brethren in one day, both in a mutual destiny involved, self-slaughtered, both the.

Antigone's predicament coincides in many ways with socrates' ethical dilemma in plato's “apology” and the “crito ” socrates has argued that one must obey one's superior, someone who is relevantly wiser than oneself, the god in ethical matters , in any situation in which one's only reason not to obey is that obedience puts. The drama of “antigone” hinges on the conflict between competing moral claims for kreon, good citizenship trumps all after a bloody civil war, he demands law and order: “obedience saves lives obedience must be defended” in antigone's transgression, he sees the dangerous primacy of personal will. Such a view would ignore the dialectical relationship between obedience and disobedience whenever the principles which are obeyed and those which are disobeyed are irreconcilable, an act of obedience to one principle is necessarily an act of disobedience to its counterpart, and vice versa antigone is. Penned by sophocles sometime before 441 bc, “antigone” is a tragedy that criticizes the often-arbitrary laws of man, which sophocles argues are of lesser value than one's own moral and personal obligations playwright paula cizmar's “antigone x” relies on the laurels of the classical play, placing the.

When creon questions him about his loyalties, haemon replies that no woman is as important as his father and that he will obey creon pleased before leaving, antigone gives one last defense: she would not have defied creon if the unburied corpse were her husband's or her child's, for either could be replaced only for. Disobedience is permitted if it will promote social good one further point about theories of law and our duty to obey: there is no simple correspondence between our theories of law and theories of obligation to obey for instance, we can certainly think of fine moral reasons not to break contracts, commit fraud, and violence. The ethics of antigone claudia hauer sophocles' play antigone remains one of the most compelling and oft-performed of the greek tragedies, and is a regular on common core english class syllabi students, who can certainly feel the antigone's timeless power, are asked in class to explore many elements: plot, character,. One's personal conscience, to be thought out by the individual as a moral problem and not a legal issue all laws which were valid under the rules of recognition created a corresponding legal obligation of obedience21 the validity of the law could not be disproved by showing that its requirements were evil.

In sophocles' antigone, a written dramatic play, sophocles portrays the theme that at times of one's life, it is necessary to follow moral law and ignore political law in the play, a determined and courageous woman named antigone is loyal to her beloved brother by granting him a proper burial and having to suffer the. An examination of the ethics in antigone, a play by sophocles no private obligation was more sacred and more imperative in the eyes of the greeks than the duty she undertook, and which, as the last of her race, ismene excepted, she could delegate to no one else she had a right to look upon it as a divine commission. One such daughter, antigone, is faced with a moral dilemma: her uncle creon ( now king of the city) has decreed that her brother polynices, who had raised think that religion requires life-or-death strict adherence to ritual and that, of course, unquestioned obedience to the state isn't a moral requirement.

Antigone the obedience of ones morality

antigone the obedience of ones morality Mature comprehension of socrates,2 found that refusal to obey a law result- ed not in loss of life but in find it difficult to understand why one who acts rightly should be expected to invite wrongful punishment aggravated, form than antigone's moral problem for the citizen here believes that he is being loyal to the.

For many people, obedience is a deeply ingrained behavior tendency, indeed a potent impulse overriding training in ethics, sympathy, and moral conduct as the story of abraham, and the question of whether one should obey when commands conflict with conscience has been argued by plato, dramatized in antigone,.

  • Eternal and natural law: the foundation of morals and law - for moral order to exist, there must be an objective moral law easily perceived, common to all when positive law is not based on natural law, it is not a true law we are not obliged to obey it, and sometimes cannot obey it, as in antigone.
  • The morality of the ancient hebrews was not rooted in conscience, but in obedience to divine commands, according to van creveld a royal command to leave her brother unburied, on the one hand, and flouting the king's authority, on the other, antigone hears an inner voice that compels her to rebel.
  • Does one have a moral obligation to always obey the law conversely, should one obey an unjust law obviously, such an individual like antigone in ancient greece is naturally torn between two loyalties (note 1)if he obeys the law, he would be guilty of knowingly aiding to sustain an unjust system if he follows his moral.

I myself am not inclined to think that being law abiding has anything to do with one's moral consciousness in order to be law-abiding, one need only obey the laws and in order to do this, one need only know the laws, one needn't even understand them so even basic legal knowledge is not a condition for. Moral right in order to address the first point, i will begin by analyzing the reasoning behind antigone's decision to bury her brother polyneices, despite eteocles and polyneices, who killed one another in a classic bruderkrieg6 it also fight against men, and that we are ruled, by those who are stronger, to obedience in. Antigone: the obedience of one's morality according to the bible, after jesus was arrested by religious leaders, the apostles, his closest followers, fled his side the apostle peter was later recognized as one of jesus' companions by the people who helped arrest him peter, however, denied even knowing jesus three. Conflict between individual morals and state laws in antigone and a doll's house mother, should i trust the government or should i trust myself this dilemma is a common one in a great deal of literature in antigone and a doll's house, the main theme is the question of whether one should be true to oneself or true to.

antigone the obedience of ones morality Mature comprehension of socrates,2 found that refusal to obey a law result- ed not in loss of life but in find it difficult to understand why one who acts rightly should be expected to invite wrongful punishment aggravated, form than antigone's moral problem for the citizen here believes that he is being loyal to the. antigone the obedience of ones morality Mature comprehension of socrates,2 found that refusal to obey a law result- ed not in loss of life but in find it difficult to understand why one who acts rightly should be expected to invite wrongful punishment aggravated, form than antigone's moral problem for the citizen here believes that he is being loyal to the.
Antigone the obedience of ones morality
Rated 3/5 based on 38 review